Guest Blog | 2 Comments |
Book review: Shattered Nation
Shattered Nation: Inequality and the Geography of a Failing State
Author: Danny Dorling
Publisher: Verso Books, 2023
ISBN-13: 978-1-80429-327-0
Price: £5.99 e-book; £14.99 paperback (link to Amazon will open in a new browser window)
Reviewed by: Mo Stewart
Wrong path willingly taken
‘Many of those previously just-coping can no longer cope’ is a statement in the first chapter of this fascinating book as Danny Dorling testifies as to why the nation is ‘shattered’ by identifying the wrong path willingly taken by every successive UK administration since Thatcher, leading to increased inequality and devastating poverty for many.
With personal observations of the negative changes in his Oxford home city over the past forty years, and by visiting areas across the UK, Dorling expertly demonstrates how successive administrations devoted to profit, not people, constantly adopted policies to favour the rich regardless of human consequences which inevitably made the poor poorer.
The fabric of society was transformed by Margaret Thatcher’s right-leaning ideology (1979–90) and was continued by every successive administration, as the past moral compass of distant administrations was abandoned with a government now so far to the right that it has identified the UK as being the most unequal country in Europe.
Five Beveridge Giants return in new forms
There is no stone left unturned in this book, which is a page-turner, demonstrating how every element of society was negatively impacted over the years by a devotion to cost, not care, as the five giants of poverty as first identified in the 1940s by the Beveridge Report ‘are returning in new forms’ to justify what are morally reprehensible social policies devoted to ideology which have ‘shattered’ those in greatest need in a once great nation.
Dorling devotes a chapter to the human geography of each of the identified five new giants of squalor which are hunger, precarity, waste, exploitation, and fear as now all found in C21st UK which joins Bulgaria as being ‘jointly top’ in the OECD league table of inequality in Europe.
A roadmap of preventable harm
The book is a roadmap of the preventable harm created by successive right-leaning UK administrations who objected to rising welfare costs which are guaranteed to increase over time with an ageing population. Successive administrations adopted unethical social policies to successfully intimidate the chronically ill and disabled community for claiming disability benefit as policies recreated the ideology of the ‘poor laws’ from past centuries, insisting that anyone living in poverty only has themselves to blame.
The so called minimum wages are essentially poverty wages, which people can’t survive on, and their increasing debt and poverty is of little interest as successive administrations accept no responsibility for the destitution now experienced by so many as they ‘use hunger to control others’, and the UK remains distant from most of Europe when conducting welfare management. Dorling also identifies the fact that ‘a state shatters when greed is put on a pedestal’. Never a truer statement was ever made.
Workers paid less, work longer hours
He goes into great detail when comparing the size of the decline of various industries especially in the twenty years between 1999 and 2019. He highlights the drop in the various trades, together with the impact on the housing market and increases in the rental market, and all this happened long before the negative impact of the pandemic with the exploitation of the work force as ‘far more of those workers are now paid less than their predecessors and often have to work longer hours’.
Dorling also identifies the business activities which have grown the most since 1999, which includes personal service activities such as dry cleaning and hairdressing, with an emphasis on the increase in the numbers of funeral parlours.
Devotion to profit and greed
The book content stresses the inequality that dominates UK society, the devotion to profit and greed and the failure to recognise ‘what matters most’. ‘Everything is judged in financial terms or by tick-box targets that devalue what is truly worthwhile and what actually adds to the greater good’.
Return of diseases of poverty
Dorling identifies the fear people now live with, the impact on mental health and life expectancy on those in greatest need since austerity measures were adopted, and the increasing feelings of ‘shame, self-blame, isolation, fear and guilt’, with an identified disturbing increase in the suffering of the poor from previous generations in ‘the unexpected return of some of the diseases of Beveridge’s day: rickets, polio and tuberculosis’.
Creeping privatisation of NHS
There is also concern expressed at the identified amount of private providers creeping into the NHS as ‘in the richest parts of the UK, a quarter of all NHS care was being provided by private hospitals and private providers’. Indeed, ‘between 2015 and 2019 the value of private sector NHS contracts increased by 89 per cent’.
It is chilling to note Dorling’s observation that from ‘being above all other large European countries for life expectancy in the 1950s, the UK dropped below the rest of Western Europe by 2021’.
A catalogue of disquiet
This book is a catalogue of disquiet as it identifies the consequences of various policies adopted over the years which have negatively impacted on all aspects of human need including housing, food poverty, social policies, mental health, utilities, homelessness, water, education, transport, the NHS, and excessive rent and mortgage increases, which all contribute to the infringement of quality of life imposed by successive right-leaning administrations, which is why the once great UK is correctly identified by Dorling as being a ‘shattered’ nation.
Article ends – click to return to top or check out related resources below
Further reading and resources
Mo Stewart is the Research Lead for the Preventable Harm Project that ran for ten years from 2009-2019. (external link will open in a new browser tab or window) The Project exposed the long-held political ambition to demolish the UK welfare state to be eventually replaced with private health insurance, similar to the system used in America.
Review: “Cash Not Care: the planned demolition of the UK welfare state” by Mo Stewart
More from Mo Stewart and the Preventable Harm Project

I was born in 1953, working class family, council house kid, when it did not have the stigma and perceptions it has today. My father was killed in an industrial accident when I was just ten years old, my mother had to bring up four kids in her early thirties on a meagre benefit, called Industrial Death Benefit and a small amount of family allowance (nothing then for the first born), god knows how she did it.
Seventy years on there is a raft of social security benefits, albeit means tested, everyone of them overly complicated to apply for, and like drug addiction traps people in a cycle of ‘poverty’ and ‘inactivity’, supports the payment of low wages, accounting for a massive proportion of tax revenue in a vicious circle of falling back on disproportional less well off.
It could be argued that the very same social security system has enabled the country to deindustrialise, de-skill and promote a low paid service sector whilst locked in a downward spiral of social decay and impoverishment, at the same time sucking in vast amounts of imports further adding to the redundancy of the working classes as the engine house of growth and sustainable local productivity.
The conundrum now is how do we solve the problem of decline, both major political parties do not have the answer, its leaders and MP’s locked in an idealogical battle, wasting time screaming at each other over a ballot box or newspaper headline, with little understanding of the problems, and no actual experience or skills to perform their functions of national management, or even local management. Throw into the mix a crumbling health and the non existence of a social care structure and things will only get worst as the rot as set in on what was a poorly underpinned establishment in the first instance. Meanwhile what is left is cherry picked by foreign companies to exploit what remaining profit can be extracted on providing reduced services, making the UK and its now overly complicated geo political parts in all but name a failing ‘Third World Country’.
My lifetime is in it final stages, but I fear for my children and their children, it has been a series boom and busts, exploited by some for personal gain whilst giving nothing back, a case of ‘I am alright jack, pull up the ladder’ and at every level of society, the trouble is the ‘pile of dispossessed and deprived’ at the bottom is getting bigger, soon the ‘stench’ will be overwhelming and the whole system will collapse on its rotten foundations.
This looks like an interesting and valid read. Is there a mention of Brexit in there, as there should be? An excuse for a massive power grab by the rich on the poor and an opportunity to dismantle and deregulate, undermining workers rights, destabilising the NHS, etc. I imagine it’s in the book somewhere, but it’s not mentioned in your review so I wonder…….