Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans
Emergency evacuation for disabled people
Three times the Government has dismissed the Grenfell Tower Inquiry’s recommendation for personal emergency evacuation plans for disabled people living in high rise buildings. 40% of disabled inhabitants died in the horrific fire.
Update August 2025 – New requirement for residential Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans (PEEPs)
The government has now followed the recommendation of the phase one report of the Grenfell Tower Inquiry, and is requiring owners and managers of certain high-rise and higher-risk residential buildings to prepare Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans (PEEPs) for residents who may struggle to evacuate independently in a fire. The new regulations, introduced by the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government, will come into force in April 2026.
Which buildings are covered?
The rules apply to residential buildings that:
• Are at least 18 metres / 7 storeys high, or
• Over 11 metres with a simultaneous evacuation strategy in place.
Who is eligible for a PEEP?
A PEEP is for residents whose ability to evacuate is limited due to a disability, health condition, or cognitive impairment.
What must a PEEP include?
Building owners/managers (the “Responsible Person”) must:
• Offer a person-centred fire risk assessment tailored to the resident.
• Identify reasonable and proportionate measures to reduce risks.
• Provide a written evacuation statement for the resident.
• Share key information with the local Fire and Rescue Service, with the resident’s consent.
Consent is required at every stage, and residents can choose how much they wish to participate.
Costs and responsibilities
The Responsible Person decides which measures are “reasonable and proportionate”.
Residents cannot be forced to pay for measures they do not want.
Leaseholder rights and shared property agreements are not overridden.
Enforcement
Fire and Rescue Authorities will enforce compliance. Residents can raise concerns with the building’s Accountable Person or escalate to the Building Safety Regulator.
Supporting toolkit
The government has also issued a Residential PEEPs Toolkit, available to all building managers. It provides practical examples on:
• Person-centred assessments
• Resident engagement
• In-flat safety measures (such as light alarms, vibrating pillows, sprinklers)
• Information sharing with Fire and Rescue Services
Further statutory guidance is expected in Autumn 2025.
Update July 2023
The latest twist in the convoluted saga of Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans, or PEEPs.
The High Court finds that the Government made a secret political decision not to implement the recommendations of the Grenfell Inquiry on PEEPs, but nevertheless refuses application for judicial review…
Costs outweigh safety considerations
The High Court ruling determined that the British Government made an “essentially political decision” that prioritised practical and cost considerations over the urgent public safety imperative outlined in the Phase 1 report of the Grenfell Tower Inquiry. The decision came as a result of judicial review proceedings initiated by Bhatt Murphy on behalf of Sarah Rennie, Georgie Hulme, and CLADDAG, an organisation advocating for disabled leaseholders and tenants affected by the building safety crisis.
The Grenfell Tower Inquiry Chair, in October 2019, issued crucial fire safety recommendations, including the establishment of legal requirements for owners and managers of high-rise residential buildings to develop Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans (PEEPs) for residents with compromised abilities to self-evacuate during emergencies. These recommendations aimed to ensure relevant and up-to-date information about such residents and their PEEPs would be readily available in premises information boxes.
PEEPs consultation outcome challenged
The claimants initiated the judicial review proceedings to challenge the outcome of a consultation known as the PEEPs consultation, which itself was a result of an earlier judicial review brought by a bereaved family member of a disabled tenant who lost their life in the Grenfell Tower fire.
The PEEPs consultation sought input on four proposals that would require the preparation of PEEPs for disabled residents in high-rise residential buildings. The overwhelming majority of respondents supported the implementation of these proposals. However, the government’s response on May 18, 2022, indicated a decision not to mandate PEEPs for disabled residents in high-rise buildings due to concerns over safety, proportionality, and practicality. Instead, a subsequent government consultation was launched to gather feedback on new proposals, known as the EEIS+ proposals, which fell short of implementing the PEEPs recommendations and only applied to a small portion of high-rise residential buildings.
High Court hearing last December
During a two-day hearing in the High Court in December 2022, the claimants argued that the decision to reject the PEEPs recommendations was unlawful for various reasons. They claimed that the government failed to grasp the rationale behind the recommendations, that the public consultation process was unfair, that there was a failure to comply with the Public Sector Equality Duty, and that the government’s inaction breached disabled residents’ rights to life and freedom from discrimination under the European Convention on Human Rights.
The government’s primary defense was that no decision had been made to reject the PEEPs recommendations and that they were still considering how to implement the Chair’s recommendations. However, the judge unequivocally dismissed this argument, stating that a decision had been definitively made not to implement the PEEPs recommendations by late March 2022.
Political decision outside the court’s jurisdiction
Internal records, obtained through a disclosure application, revealed Ministerial concern about publicly rejecting the recommendations due to potential political difficulties. The judge concluded that the decision to reject the recommendations was political in nature and therefore beyond the court’s jurisdiction. This ruling deeply disappointed the claimants and many others who had hoped for the implementation of the carefully considered PEEPs recommendations.
Government should stand by its commitments
The claimants now urge the government to honour its previous commitments to implement the PEEPs recommendations, and they call on the Grenfell Tower public inquiry to critically scrutinise the government’s decision to reject the recommendations based on the extensive evidence presented before and since the recommendations were made.
The Grenfell Tower fire on June 14, 2017, claimed the lives of 72 individuals, a disproportionate number of whom were disabled. Their ability to evacuate through the sole means of escape, a single staircase, was compromised due to the lack of plans or arrangements to assist them in case of a fire. Under the government’s current EEIS+ proposals, responsible persons of buildings would still not be obligated to implement such plans, perpetuating potential risks for disabled residents.
Sarah Rennie & Georgie Hulme responded to the judgment as follows:
“The Court’s judgment makes clearer than ever to us and our community that a political decision has been made by this Government to leave disabled and older people living in high rise buildings without means of escape. It is a decision taken without listening to the experts and persons with lived experience who hold the answers to perceived practical difficulties. It is a decision to prioritise money over disabled persons’ lives. And it is a decision not to learn the lessons of the disproportionate deaths of disabled persons in the Grenfell Tower fire as identified by the Chair of the public inquiry.
However, this case has sparked a national conversation. Our supporters within the housing sector and fire safety industry have noted a significant shift in thinking on this issue over the last 12 months and the inhumane ‘stay put’ mantra has, at long last, lost its dangerous grip.
We thank our legal team for their unwavering dedication together with Law for Change and everyone who has supported us to pursue this judicial review. Our small part in the pursuit of justice will continue.”
Update November 2022
Thanks to a crowdfunding appeal (see below) CLADDAG have raised over £21,500 and can now proceed with the legal challenge to the government’s decision without personal risk.
They are particularly grateful to Law for Change without whom they would not have reached the target. They kicked off the crowdfunding campaign with a generous donation of £10,000 and have now pledged the remaining funds needed.
The hearing is set for 6-7 December 2022 at the Royal Courts of Justice in London. CLADDAG plan to attend in person as much as they are physically able to and subject to the court’s willingness to make reasonable adjustments.
When remediation works start…
Another aspect of the problems for elderly and disabled people living in a high-rise buildings is the significant impact of remediation work, when this is undertaken to make the buildings safer. CLADDAG have written about the lack of planning and protective measures from the Government in relation to vulnerable residents.
Here is a link to the blog, which also includes a contact for the Department of Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, so you can get in touch directly with any worries or experiences (external link will open in a new browser tab or window).
Update September 2022
The High Court has now given permission to CLADDAG to apply for judicial review of the government’s decision. This means that the judge considered they have an arguable case and that it should be brought before the court swiftly. They hope that the hearing will take place before the end of the year.
The judge also agreed to grant a cost capping order as this is a public interest case. This means that if the case is not successful CLADDAG will only have to pay the Home Office’s legal fees up to the sum of £20,000, together with Court fees which are estimated to be up to £1,500.
This is still a lot of money that they don’t have. Law for Change has donated £10,000 and campaign supporters have given an additional £5,805 so far through the crowdfunding appeal. So they need to raise a further £5,695 in order to proceed.
If you would like to support the campaign, you can make a donation here (external link will open in a new browser tab or window)
Their legal team are working on a ‘no win no fee’ basis, and if they are successful all unused donations will be returned.
Update August 2022 – Claddag requesting campaign action
Do you need an evacuation plan? Do you support evacuation plans? If you need one, or are an ally and would like to get involved, one way is to have a photo taken with one of the Claddag campaign signs.
Or you can make your own. Use your own text or only the photo. Please share on social media. If you are on Twitter, please tag @Claddag, your MP, metro mayor and anyone else you feel is relevant. Please use hashtags #EVACPLANSNOW #NOTJUSTWHEELCHAIRS
Or you can email your photos to Claddag to share.
Let’s try and show our diversity and humanity in the fight for Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans (PEEPs).
Here is a link to the signs (external link will open in a new browser tab or window)
‘I Need An Evacuation Plan.’
‘I Support Evacuation Plans.’
March 1st 2022 – Claddag fighting for equal access to fire safety
Claddag is a small but energetic residents action group, founded by two wheelchair users, Sarah Rennie and Georgie Hulme. They contributed to the consultation on Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans last summer, to which there should have been a government response last October, but this is still awaited.
Sarah Rennie has lived in a block of flats in Birmingham since 2008. She is a wheelchair user and, for over 10 years, was advised by the Fire Service to stay put and not attempt to evacuate.
She explains her situation:
“After the Grenfell Tower tragedy. I felt frightened to stay in my flat when everyone else was ordered to immediately evacuate when the klaxons are sounded. I approached my managing agents for a personal evacuation plan but their advisors told them it was a matter for the Fire Service. I found an independent expert to help me draw up a plan and, with the support of the building’s Board, follow it myself anyway. But this makes me one of the lucky ones. I feel sick to my stomach that the authors of the LGA guidance are being commissioned by the Government to further influence policy on the lives of disabled people.”
Co-founder Georgie Hulme is fighting for an evacuation plan:
“I also live in a flat where the evacuation guidance changed from ‘stay put’ to ‘simultaneous evacuation.’ However, like so many other disabled, I was refused an evacuation plan. I was informed that I would need to wait for the Fire Service to attend before I could evacuate. Like Sarah, I obtained expert advice and embarrassingly crowdfunded for an evac chair, just to feel safer, even though neither are ‘officially’ recognised. I felt that there was some hope following the Government’s consultation last year, but now it feels that disabled people will have to continue the same fight, when all we want is an equal right to evacuate residential buildings in an emergency. There is no reason to think any lessons have been learnt and, as is often the case, our lives will continue to be viewed as inferior. I feel upset and angry that the Home Office have agreed this, especially considering the history.”
The Grenfell Tower Inquiry heard that 41% of the disabled residents of the tower died during the fire
As part of the consultation on the LGA guidance, the Chief Fire Officers Association stated that “to ignore and eliminate advice on disabled access and evacuation is a fundamental error of the document.”
Disabled people living in blocks of flats are fighting the legacy of the ‘stay put’ ethos every day. Claddag are frequently contacted by disabled people who cannot secure evacuation plans from their managing agents or even the support of their local fire service. This is despite the Government’s proposals, consulted upon last year, to require managing agents to implement them in a U-turn approach.
Means of Escape guidance commissioned from company advocating against evacuation plans
Claddag were shocked and outraged to learn that the Home Office had commissioned C S Todd & Associates to re-write the Means of Escape for Disabled People, and the other suite of fire safety guidance documents.
C S Todd & Associates authored the guidance document Fire Safety in Purpose-Built Flats, published by the Local Government Association (LGA) in 2011 with the support of Government, which has been the subject of judicial review. Fire safety consultant Elspeth Grant actually wrote to the LGA at the time, warning that it discriminated unlawfully against disabled people and could lead to an unnecessary tragedy.
This guidance advised building managers for ten years that it was “unrealistic” to prepare emergency evacuation plans for disabled residents. The specific wording which legitimised a less robust approach to disabled people was redacted by the Government late last year, shortly after there was a threat of legal action by the family of disabled resident who lost their life in Grenfell Tower.
By awarding yet another contract to the authors of that guidance, the Government sends a message of endorsement of this discriminatory approach and demonstrates that it has learned nothing from the judicial review or the Grenfell Tower tragedy.
Mercedes F1 condemned over Kingspan sponsorship
Last year, the Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, boldly condemned Mercedes F1 for a sponsorship with Grenfell insulation firm, Kingspan. That was a private commercial arrangement.
The guidance which has been commissioned from CS Todd & Associates is a Home Office contract. Claddag has asked Michael Gove – and Lord Greenhalgh (Minister of State for Building Safety and Fire) – for urgent comment and intervention.
Disabled people’s lives are of no less value. The LGA guidance, for which C S Todd & Associates were commissioned as editors, legitimised a discriminatory approach to disabled people. The legacy of that guidance still has to be fought every day.
Claddag taking legal action against the Home Secretary
Claddag has now taken the decision to commence judicial review proceedings against the Home Secretary for awarding the contract to CS Todd & Associates.
Colin Todd has consistently advocated against evacuation plans for disabled people. He was the sole expert to do so at the Grenfell Tower inquiry, and this should disqualify him from having such influence and authority over the safety of disabled people.
In awarding this contract, Claddag believes that the Home Secretary has failed in her public sector equality duty towards disabled people. The denial of a right to evacuation plans is a huge hidden injustice faced by private tenants, social housing tenants and leaseholders alike.
Bhatt Murphy solicitors are acting on their behalf.
Claddag not a lone voice…
Paralympian and disability rights campaigner, Baroness Grey-Thompson has raised grave concerns in the House of Lords. There is a link to her speech on YouTube at the bottom of this article.
Various individuals and other groups/organisations have also written to the Home Secretary raising their concerns. Grenfell United have submitted a letter saying “Colin Todd should not be allowed anywhere near” this guidance.
Disability Rights UK have also written to her (PDF file will open in a new browser tab or window)
As an alternative to providing Personal Emergency Evacuation Plans, Colin Todd proposes trialling a pendant with a microchip inside, that would track the movements of disabled people. He has written about this in the Institute of Fire Engineers Journal and been interviewed in the Disability News Service.
Article ends – click to return to top or check out related resources below
Further reading and resources
(external links will open in a new browser tab or window)
Keep up with developments from Claddag on their website
You can read more about the legal action on the Disability News Service website
Watch Baroness Grey-Thompson’s speech in the House of Lords
Emergency lifting and transfer

I wonder if any designers consider that disabled people might use their buildings. This is a similar issue. High rise buildings include hospitals, where people are often bed bound. Even a 2 story hospital would need an evacuation plan. I am wondering what would happen if the local hospitals here had a fire. I can remember one where I think there was smoke, small fire in a ward down the corridor, but the advice was to shut the doors and stay put. Visitors were allowed to leave, I would have had to leave my Husband behind. People homes must be priority, but next area to look at should be care facilities such as hospitals, nursing homes and sheltered flats, The list goes on. Even balconies with fire escapes, both for flats and other buildings are needed.
Hello Carol
I’m pleased to say all public buildings are already required to have emergency evacuation plans in place. Both a general plan and one specifically for people with mobility needs.
Best wishes,
Frances
Why would put disabled people in high rise flats in the first place.
If a person is that disabled wouldn’t it be common sense to give them
The bottom flats same as young families with children,.
And why build them that high in the first place,
There’s plenty of houses empty that could be occupied why no spend money on them instead .
It’s not the house’s that’s at fault it’s the people that’s put in them.
Sorry for been harsh but is true,
Any street could be fantastic if only people where vetted first .
Trouble to day there’s no respect for anyone anymore.
This is horrendously Unjust and Discriminatory act by the Home Secretary and against the spirit if not the letter of the Equalities Act and should be challenged.