Industry News | Nov 21, 2025 | No Comments |
UC: Sanctionable Failures
Universal Credit – Report on sanctionable failures
The Public Law Project’s Sanctionable Failures report examines how Universal Credit sanctions are being used in practice, despite government commitments to move toward more personalised employment support. In reality, sanction levels remain extremely high: January 2025 saw almost 65,000 sanctions, the highest on record.
Sanctions are usually triggered by minor, first-time ‘failures’, often caused by circumstances outside people’s control. Yet the consequences are severe: most sanctioned claimants lose all of their Universal Credit standard allowance for periods ranging from a week to six months or more — penalties that exceed the average criminal fine. The harm reported includes worsened physical and mental health, debt, food bank use, and reduced ability to seek work.
Drawing on 18 months of casework by Central England Law Centre, the report shows systemic failings at every stage — from the way conditions are set, to the decision to sanction, to the barriers people face in challenging decisions. With 86% of appealed sanctions overturned, many should never have been imposed at all. Given the level of harm involved, the report concludes that the current sanctions regime is not only unjust, but ineffective on its own terms.
Summary of Findings
1. A disproportionate system
Sanctions are often issued for first-time, low-level ‘failures’.
Penalties are extreme, removing 100% of a person’s standard allowance.
Because of the way sanction lengths are calculated, low-level failures can result in harsher penalties than more serious ones.
2. A harmful system
Losing the entire standard allowance pushes people into debt and food bank use.
Claimants report damage to their health, housing stability and ability to find work.
The sanctions system is therefore undermining the very outcomes it is supposed to promote.
3. An unsound system
Failures occur at every step: inconsistent use of interpreters, incorrect information, unrealistic expectations placed on claimants, and processes that do not match people’s real lives.
86% of sanctions appealed were overturned, indicating widespread misapplication.
Appeals take so long that hardship is unavoidable, even when the claimant eventually wins.
4. An unequal system
People are frequently sanctioned because of barriers they cannot control — language, digital exclusion, disability, or unfamiliarity with the system.
Groups already facing disadvantage are more likely to be sanctioned, including claimants from non-white ethnic backgrounds.
The very factors that increase the risk of sanctions also make it harder for people to challenge them.
Recommendations on sanctionable failures
1. Improve data and transparency
Government must urgently build a clearer understanding of who is affected by sanctions and conditionality, and publish this information transparently.
2. Revoke — or fundamentally reform — the sanctions regime
If the current system is not abolished, it should be overhauled to:
• apply sanctions only in exceptional circumstances, with clear warnings;
• reduce their severity, for example by introducing a protected minimum floor so people are not left with nothing.
3. Strengthen safeguards and improve access to justice
Government should:
• improve the pre-sanction checks designed to prevent inappropriate decisions;
• make reviews and appeals easier to access and navigate;
• design all safeguards with the needs of people who face additional barriers in mind, including those with limited English, refugees, and people on the wrong side of the digital divide.
Article ends – click to return to top or check out related resources below
Further reading and resources
You can download the Sanctionable Failures report on the Public Law Project website (external link will open in a new browser tab or window)

Be the first to comment.