CASCAIDr CIC | CASCAIDr CIC
See more from CASCAIDr CICCASCAIDr CIC Alert Service
(external links below will open in a new browser tab or window)
CASCAIDr CIC’s Alert Service (from which the regularly changing snippets below have been taken) keeps you up-to-date with significant judicial decisions, ombudsmen’s reports and law and policy changes from across the field, and from other commentators. It costs just £50 per year, for individual use.
Subscribers also get access to specialist legal framework briefings. The first provides guidance on the rights of unpaid carers under the Care Act – inexplicably not included in the Statutory Guidance…
The second briefing has recently been published, looking at NHS Continuing Healthcare (CHC): what it is, when to ask about it, what should happen during an eligibility consideration, and what to do if a decision or care arrangement seems wrong.
There will be seven further briefings over the year. You can subscribe to the alert service here.
Several of the most recent commentaries from CASCAIDr CIC focus on Carers – and their difficulties when public bodies ignore the legal framework. None of the councils’ internal complaints processes offered compensation despite acknowledging fault; it took the Ombudsman to get any financial redress (and even then, only Bexley paid anything). Two of these cases are summarised below.
Ombudsman’s findings on North Yorkshire Council
A man with learning disabilities, autism and anxiety relied on his mother as his main carer alongside a council-funded package. When the family gave clear notice that she would need surgery and be unable to care for him from December 2024, North Yorkshire’s social worker held a multi-disciplinary meeting but kept no minutes, then failed to follow up until late November — leaving his sister and her husband to give up work over Christmas and into January to become full-time carers themselves.
The council upheld the complaint, accepting its communication had been poor and sporadic, and that reallocating the case to a new social worker had lost the urgency of the family’s situation, but it offered no compensation — and never had to say what it would have done had the family not stepped in, or whether the couple were ever paid for the care they provided. CASCAIDr CIC’s full report examines the duty on councils to plan ahead for a foreseeable gap in unpaid care once a carer has given notice they will be unavailable, and why simply recording this as “fault” understates what actually happened.
Ombudsman’s findings on Bexley Council
An elderly woman with vascular dementia was repeatedly discharged home from hospital without a mental capacity assessment or proper consideration of a care home placement, despite records showing she couldn’t remember she was in hospital, needed help to mobilise, and was increasingly anxious and reliant on a pendant alarm. Her family repeatedly flagged both her decline and their own exhaustion, yet review after review kept her on the same package of four 45-minute calls a day.
Bexley accepted it should have tested her capacity, that it never completed the carers’ assessments the evidence called for, and that it had over-relied on her own responses and on monitoring equipment to manage risk — paying £700 in compensation, though none of the reconsiderations explained why the care package wasn’t increased or the setting changed. CASCAIDr CIC’s full report stresses that decisions about care settings and package size must follow from a rigorous analysis of needs and risk, not from repeating a standard offer at each review.
Ombudsman’s findings on Salford City Council
Salford City Council has come under fire after the Ombudsman found it failed a disabled man who moved into the area needing ongoing care. Despite already being judged eligible for support in six areas by his previous council, Salford’s social care team delayed assessing him properly, finding him ineligible and steering him towards through community “strengths” – the availability of which was not verified.
The man was left unable to go out, eat properly, or live safely. The right to continuity of care when moving areas was botched; the council approached assessment in an unlawful manner, dragged its feet over reassessment, and took too long to set up support after finally admitting he was indeed eligible for ⅔ of the support he’d had in his plan in the original council area.
CASCAIDr CIC’s full report explores the very special nature of the legal duty to underwrite continuity of care, pending local re-assessment, for Care Act clients moving area, of their own initiative.
Ombudsman’s findings on West Northamptonshire Council
A West Northants woman detained under s3 of the Mental Health Act was discharged from an NHS hospital without a legally required s117 aftercare plan. For more than a year, she lived without clear support or accountability, while her repeated complaints were mishandled — leaving her frustrated and unwell, attempting suicide a number of times.
She had received intensive therapy in a private hospital before being transferred to an NHS hospital. The NHS Trust admitted there were “unanswered questions” about who should fund her aftercare but insisted that this hadn’t delayed her assessments. It also accepted it hadn’t asked the local council or health board to join review meetings, as required by law.
The Trust argued it did the best it could within the limits of an acute service, but its handling of the complaint suggested it missed the core issue: that its failures had left other public bodies in breach of their legal duty to assess for, fund and arrange free aftercare.
CASCAIDr CIC’s full report considers whether the woman should have been repaid for aftercare she’d funded privately, which often happens in Ombudsman’s reports.
Ombudsman’s findings on Portsmouth City Council
Portsmouth City Council told a woman’s adult daughter that it could ignore the value of her mother’s home when working out care costs, making it seem like this would definitely happen. Because of this, the daughter made choices that ended up hurting her financially.
Later, Portsmouth lawfully decided not to apply the mandatory disregard, and also refused to use its discretion to ignore the property value, but did so after a poor process that did not follow the official rules or legal standards. This decision would have left the daughter without a home, but Portsmouth did not appear to consider this risk when deciding what was in the public interest.
Ombudsman’s findings on North Lincolnshire Council
North Lincolnshire Council overlooked updating a generous and flexible direct payment budget and the care plan, and did not clearly explain what parts of the budget (like money for respite or wellbeing) could actually be used for. Because of this, they later asked the client’s estate to pay back £1,700 for what they said was technically misuse.
The NHS had taken over and backdated Continuing Healthcare (CHC) funding for a long period before the person died, but would not pay the council back for some costs.
However, this was not the fault of the person who had run the direct payment, because the Council still had duties under the Care Act to give clear information and support.
Ombudsman’s findings on Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council
Families should only ever be asked to pay extra for wants, by way of top-up, not needs, which councils are legally required to fund.
In the Tameside report, there was a system of top-ups in operation in a care home, for increased dependency levels. The client’s dependency went down and the person’s relative thought that the top-up he was paying should have gone down; the Ombudsman agreed, which is fine as far as it goes; but in legal terms, the top-up should never have been charged to the relative in the first place!
Dependency scores are an aspect of need, and not want – and should be covered by the council, not pushed onto families. A council will always know if top-ups are being asked for because they are legally obliged to cover the whole fee, as a matter of contract law.
Check out this excellent panel discussion on YouTube: Funding Disputes and Client Rights: What Providers Need to Know (external link will open in a new browser tab or window)
Visit the CASCAIDr website for a wealth of information about adult social care law (external link will open in a new browser tab or window).
